JustoCard Pro

Get the Justo price—fair, exact, and backed by real comps.

RAW CARDSGRADED SLABSSEALED WAX

There are tons of cards out there—maybe too many. Endless parallels, shifting prices, and confusing grading fees hurt the hobby. That's why I created JustoCard Pro—a live comps and ROI engine that gets smarter with every evaluation.

Run The Numbers

One listing. Five cards. The final word.
Exact-match research. Not guesswork.
SAMPLE EVALUATIONILLUSTRATIVE · NOT LIVE PRICES
CARD 01 / 05
01 / THE VERDICTSINGLE CARD
TARGETBUY
MLB2024Refractor

PAUL SKENES

2024 Topps Chrome · #USC88 · Rookie Refractor · Pittsburgh Pirates

REAL MARKET VALUE$65–$85Illustrative raw range
SELLER’S CHECKOUT PRICE$109.99Example ask + shipping
TOTAL COST TO GRADE$43.99Value tier + batch shipping
BACK FROM PSA90–100 DAYSBusiness days · tier assumption

DON JUSTO’S VERDICT

THE FINAL WORD
01

Good card. Wrong price.

The example checkout is above the raw range. Let the seller come to you—not the other way around.

02

Buy the card, not the trophy talk.

An award or a playoff run is a bonus. You don’t pay for something that hasn’t happened.

03

A PSA 10 is not a promise.

Grading fees eat into the win. Get sharp front and back photos before you spend another dollar.

04

Refractor doesn’t mean rare.

This card is unnumbered. Check the exact set’s published pack odds; no made-up print run.

Exact-match first. No hype tax. No guaranteed grades.01 / 05
02 / THE CONDITION

Condition & Centering

PSA 9 · PLAN CONSERVATIVELY

No photos supplied. A PSA 10 shot cannot be called from a description.

WATCH LISTSurface scratches, print lines, corners, and edges need clear photos.

CONDITION

Not inspected. Upload front and back photos for a visual check—not a guaranteed grade.

SELLER & BUYER PROTECTION

“No returns” alone is not a red flag. Confirm listing eligibility and current eBay buyer protections.

DON JUSTO’S REALITY CHECK

“A clean title ain’t a clean surface. Show me the front, show me the back, then we’ll talk.”

03 / THE REAL MARKET

COMPS RANGE VS. SELLER ASK

Sold ranges · adjacent parallels labeled · shipping where verified · illustrative data

$0$62$124$186$248WALK-AWAY $85Raw · exact match$65–$85PSA 9$85–$110PSA 10$160–$210
61–90 DAYS AGO$90Illustrative midpoint
31–60 DAYS AGO$82Illustrative midpoint
LAST 30 DAYS$75Illustrative midpoint
DON JUSTO’S REALITY CHECK

“A seller can ask anything. What somebody actually paid? That’s the number that counts.”

04 / RUN THE NUMBERS

Grade Values & PSA Math

Fees come out. Shipping comes out. What’s left is what counts.

PSA Pop / Gem RateNew Release / Pop Unverified

KEEP IT SIMPLE

RAW

Example resale
$85
Grade cost
$0
Selling fee + ship
$16.26
NET PAYOUT$68.74
THIN MARGIN

PSA 9

Example resale
$110
Grade + batch ship
$43.99
Selling fee + ship
$19.58
NET AFTER GRADING$46.43
UPSIDE, NOT A LOCK

PSA 10

Example resale
$210
Grade + batch ship
$43.99
Selling fee + ship
$32.83
NET AFTER GRADING$133.18
DON JUSTO’S REALITY CHECK

“If the deal only works at a 10, the deal doesn’t work. Don’t build your budget on a perfect grade.”

05 / YOUR NEXT MOVE

GOOD CARD. BUY IT ON YOUR TERMS.

OPENING LOWBALL$60

Start here. Leave room to meet in the middle.

FAIR TARGET BUY$75

Example target, including shipping.

WALK-AWAY MAX LANDED$85

Example landed ceiling. No trophy tax.

ACTIVE ALTERNATIVES

KEEP YOUR OPTIONS OPEN

Evaluate a listing to research exact-match alternatives.

DON JUSTO’S REALITY CHECK

“There’s always another card. Keep your cash until the price makes sense.”

0105